Skip to main content

lhiconsult

What a Compliance Remediation Programme Actually Looks Like

LHI Consulting No comments

Most firms that come out of the FCA’s authorisation process — or that have followed this series and conducted an honest review of their frameworks — have a list. A list of things that need fixing. Gaps in the financial promotions framework. A fair value assessment that hasn’t been reviewed since 2023. A SAR process that exists in policy but not in practice. An Article 22 disclosure that was never built.

The list is the easy part. What firms find harder is turning it into a programme that closes the gaps properly, in the right order, with the evidence trail the FCA would expect to see — rather than a series of ad hoc fixes assembled under pressure.

This piece is about what a structured compliance remediation programme looks like in practice: how gaps are prioritised, how the programme is sequenced, what the FCA expects to see when a firm is remediating proactively, and what distinguishes a programme that holds up under scrutiny from one that does not.

Why Remediation Is Not the Same as a To-Do List

The instinct when a compliance gap is identified is to fix it. Update the policy. Revise the notice. Add a disclosure. Brief the team. Tick the box.

That instinct is understandable, but it misses what remediation actually requires. The FCA is not looking for evidence that the policy now says the right thing. It is looking for evidence that the operational reality has changed — that the system now works, that the monitoring now runs, that the data now exists. A policy update without an operational change is not remediation. It is documentation.

The distinction matters because the FCA’s approach to firms that have self-identified and remediated proactively is meaningfully different from its approach to firms that are remediating in response to supervisory contact. The former position is materially stronger. But it only holds if the remediation is genuine — systematic, evidenced, and capable of withstanding scrutiny.

Prioritising the Gaps

Not all compliance gaps carry the same regulatory risk, and a remediation programme that attempts to address everything simultaneously typically addresses nothing properly. The starting point is a gap assessment that categorises each identified gap by two factors: the severity of the potential regulatory consequence, and the operational complexity of the fix.

Gaps that carry the highest regulatory risk and the most straightforward remediation should be addressed first. In the crypto compliance context, these typically include:

Active promotional activity without a lawful communication route. If a firm is communicating financial promotions without a section 21 approval or its own authorisation, this is a live breach with enforcement consequences. It takes priority over everything else.

Consent records that do not meet the ICO’s evidencing standard. If the firm is sending direct marketing on the basis of consent records that would not withstand ICO scrutiny, every send is a potential breach. Stopping the sends or refreshing the consent basis is an immediate priority.

Appropriateness assessments that do not function as genuine gates. If the firm’s appropriateness assessment is designed to pass everyone through, it is a live Consumer Duty and FCA breach on every use. Fixing the assessment design is high priority.

Missing Article 22 mechanisms. If the firm is running automated decision-making systems without the required disclosures and human intervention mechanisms, every automated decision is potentially non-compliant. Building the mechanisms is an immediate priority.

Lower priority — though still important — are gaps that are structural rather than live: a fair value assessment that needs updating, a retention schedule that has not been documented, a vulnerable customer register that needs to be built. These carry regulatory risk but not the same immediacy as live operational breaches.

Sequencing the Programme

Once gaps have been prioritised, the remediation programme needs to be sequenced — a realistic timeline that assigns each gap to a work stream, identifies who owns it, and sets milestone dates for completion.

The sequencing discipline serves two purposes. First, it makes the programme manageable — teams know what they are working on and in what order, rather than attempting to fix everything at once and making partial progress on all of it. Second, it creates the paper trail the FCA expects to see: a remediation plan with dates, owners, and milestones is evidence that the firm has taken the gap seriously and is addressing it systematically.

The FCA’s published guidance on proactive remediation is clear on this point. A firm that can produce a dated remediation plan, with evidence of progress against it, is in a demonstrably stronger position than a firm that responds to supervisory contact with a list of things it has since fixed but cannot demonstrate were addressed systematically.

A realistic sequencing for a crypto firm coming out of the authorisation process might look like:

Weeks 1–2: Address live operational breaches — promotions without lawful routes, marketing on stale consent, appropriateness assessment design failures. These cannot wait.

Weeks 3–6: Build the missing mechanisms — Article 22 disclosures and human intervention processes, SAR workflow and data map, affiliate monitoring documentation.

Weeks 7–12: Update structural documents — fair value assessments, retention schedules, Consumer Duty board report structure, vulnerable customer register.

Ongoing: Embed the monitoring — outcome monitoring cadence, affiliate channel audit schedule, consent record review process, DPIA review cycle.

What the FCA Expects to See

When the FCA reviews a firm that has undertaken proactive remediation, it is looking for specific things. Knowing what those are shapes how the programme should be documented.

A dated remediation plan. Not a list of things fixed, but a plan that shows the gap, the planned fix, the owner, the milestone date, and the actual completion date. This demonstrates that the remediation was systematic rather than reactive.

Evidence of operational change, not policy change. For each gap, the FCA expects to see evidence that the operational reality has changed — approval records, monitoring logs, system screenshots, training records. Policy documents updated to describe the intended state are not evidence of remediation.

An explanation of root cause. The FCA is interested in why the gap existed, not just that it has been fixed. A remediation programme that addresses root cause — why the appropriateness assessment was designed the way it was, why the affiliate monitoring was not in place — is more credible than one that simply corrects the symptom.

Ongoing monitoring. The FCA expects that the remediation does not just fix the gap but puts in place the monitoring to ensure the gap does not reopen. A cooling-off period that is now implemented should have a monthly check to confirm it is still functioning. An affiliate channel that has been audited should have a schedule for the next audit.

Worth asking:

If the FCA asked your firm today to produce its remediation plan — showing the gap, the planned fix, the owner, the milestone date, and evidence of completion — for each compliance issue identified in the last six months, how complete would that document be?

Remediating Across Multiple Regimes

For firms that have identified gaps across financial promotions, Consumer Duty, and GDPR simultaneously — which is the common position for crypto firms coming out of this series — the remediation programme needs to span all three. This creates coordination challenges that a single-regime programme does not.

The most common failure mode is parallel but unconnected remediation streams — one team fixing the financial promotions gaps, another addressing Consumer Duty, a third handling GDPR — without a shared programme view of how the fixes interact. As the earlier piece in this series on the intersection of all three regimes set out, a non-compliant marketing communication can simultaneously be a financial promotions breach, a Consumer Duty failure, and a GDPR violation. The remediation of the promotional review process should therefore address all three dimensions simultaneously — not as separate fixes that happen to overlap.

A multi-regime remediation programme needs a single owner with visibility across all three work streams, a shared remediation plan that maps interactions between fixes, and a consolidated evidence trail that the FCA and ICO can both review without needing to reconcile separate documents.

The Evidence Trail

The evidence trail is what distinguishes a remediation programme that holds up under scrutiny from one that does not. It is not a separate exercise — it is built as the programme runs.

For each gap and each fix, the evidence trail should include: the initial gap assessment documenting what was found and when; the remediation plan entry for that gap; the work product that represents the fix — the updated system, the new process document, the training record, the monitoring log; and the sign-off from the responsible senior manager confirming the fix is complete and operating.

The evidence trail serves the firm in two ways. First, it supports the firm’s position with the FCA if supervisory contact occurs during or after the remediation period. Second, it provides the basis for the board to genuinely oversee the remediation — not just to be told that gaps have been fixed, but to see the evidence that they have been.

Our compliance oversight service supports firms in building and running structured remediation programmes across financial promotions, Consumer Duty and GDPR — see how we can help.

Final Thought

The firms that manage compliance remediation most effectively are those that treat it as a programme, not a list. A programme has structure, ownership, milestones, evidence, and ongoing monitoring. A list has none of those things.

For firms coming out of the authorisation process with gaps to close, or firms that have used this series to identify areas that need attention, the question is not whether to remediate — it is how to do it in a way that is systematic, evidenced, and durable.

If you want to talk through what a remediation programme looks like for your firm’s specific gaps, speak to our team.

Book a free consultation

We help crypto firms build and run structured compliance remediation programmes across financial promotions, Consumer Duty and GDPR — closing gaps systematically and building the evidence trail the FCA expects to see.

Email: info@lhiconsult.com  |  Phone: +44 203 319 5147  |  Web: lhiconsult.com

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal or regulatory advice. LHI Consulting is a trading style of LHI Holdings Ltd, registered in England and Wales, No. 11496647.

FAQs

We have identified compliance gaps internally. Should we tell the FCA before we have fixed them?
This depends on the nature and severity of the gaps. Certain gaps — particularly live operational breaches such as communicating financial promotions without a lawful route — may trigger notification obligations. For other gaps, proactive disclosure is a judgment call that should involve legal advice. What is clear is that a firm that identifies gaps, remediates them systematically, and can demonstrate that process to the FCA is in a stronger position than one that neither discloses nor remediates.

How long should a compliance remediation programme take?
It depends on the number and complexity of the gaps. Live operational breaches should be addressed within days, not weeks. Structural gaps — documentation, monitoring frameworks, board reporting — typically require four to twelve weeks to address properly. A programme that claims to have fixed everything within two weeks is unlikely to have achieved genuine operational change; a programme that takes more than three months on straightforward gaps may not be moving with sufficient urgency.

Who should own the remediation programme?
A named senior manager with authority across all three regime areas — financial promotions, Consumer Duty, and GDPR — and with direct access to the board. The programme should not be owned by a single compliance team member without that authority; the FCA expects to see genuine senior management engagement with remediation, not just completion of tasks.

What if we find more gaps during the remediation process?
This is common. A thorough remediation process often surfaces additional gaps that were not identified in the initial assessment. These should be added to the remediation plan with the same structure — gap description, planned fix, owner, milestone date — rather than treated as separate issues. The FCA views a growing remediation plan as evidence of thoroughness, not failure.

Can we use our remediation programme as evidence in our authorisation application?
Yes. A remediation programme that demonstrates that the firm has identified gaps, taken them seriously, and is addressing them systematically is relevant to the FCA’s assessment of the firm’s governance and compliance capability. It is not a substitute for a compliant framework — the FCA expects the gaps to be closed, not just being closed — but it is material evidence of the firm’s approach to compliance.

Leave a comment